Google isn’t elevating the brands that spend the most on ads or post the flashiest imagery. It’s surfacing the businesses that best match what users want in that specific moment.
That’s why the traditional, one-size-fits-all local SEO checklist falls apart – it assumes every customer follows the same path.
Put differently, Google does have favorites, but they’re “signal-fit” favorites. Its ranking system isn’t random; it’s calibrated to intent, behavior patterns, and the nuances of each category.
Recent shifts in search behavior challenge the old belief that one approach works everywhere.
There is no single master formula behind Google’s Local Pack – it’s molded by how people actually search in the real world.
The idea that a generic playbook can drive equal success for both a burger restaurant and a dental practice doesn’t hold up, especially as search becomes more personalized to each individual.
What the data shows
Yext’s study of 8.7 million Google Business Profiles across five U.S. verticals dispels the notion that brand scale or ad spend guarantees visibility. (Disclosure: I’m the senior director of Yext Research.)
The real driver is “signal fit” – how tightly a listing lines up with what local users expect to see.
Review frequency, image quality, and profile completeness all influence performance, but their impact isn’t uniform. Google adjusts how it weights these elements by industry and even by region.
These detailed findings reinforce a core reality: Google does show preference, but that preference is anchored in how well a listing reflects local context and the user’s immediate intent.
For multi-location brands, the implication is clear: you can’t force your way into the Local Pack with volume alone. Each vertical demands its own tailored strategy, tuned to the signals that matter most there.
The “signal-fit” idea becomes clearest when you look at how it plays out by industry, where Google’s algorithm shifts to mirror distinct consumer expectations.
- Hospitality: Practical details outweigh visual flair. Accurate hours, a strong business description, and a fully completed profile are critical. Beyond a certain point, adding more photos delivers diminishing returns. Travelers care less about one more shot of the pool and more about whether there’s parking when they pull in at midnight.
- Healthcare: Access and patient satisfaction dominate. Consistent, high-quality reviews, precise hours, and a clear description of the location influence visibility far more than photos or promotional copy. Patients choose based on trust and dependability, not gloss. In healthcare, reliability over time is what builds confidence.
- Retail: When deciding if a store is worth visiting, shoppers lean heavily on other customers’ experiences. Review volume and sentiment are the strongest performance signals in this space, with one of the biggest gaps between top and bottom performers, second only to healthcare. A polished, current listing suggests an efficient operation. A neglected one implies: if you can’t manage your own information, what else might be slipping?
- Food and Dining: This is the most competitive category. Ratings and ongoing brand interaction with guests are the primary signals. While profile completeness still helps, it contributes less to visibility than in other sectors. Diners respond to signs of life: recent reviews, timely responses, and a steady stream of feedback.
- Financial Services: In “Your Money, Your Life” spaces, trust is built on both reputation and lived experience. Professional imagery can convey stability, but a continuous flow of genuine reviews and thoughtful responses does far more to earn confidence.
Regional variation doesn’t overturn the rules, but it does bend them.
In the Northeast, for example, restaurants tend to perform better when social media links are included, while in some markets, healthcare profiles gain less from photos.
These trends highlight that Google’s definition of “relevance” is inherently local.
Get the newsletter search marketers rely on.
MktoForms2.loadForm(“https://app-sj02.marketo.com”, “727-ZQE-044”, 16298, function(form) {
// form.onSubmit(function(){
// });
// form.onSuccess(function (values, followUpUrl) {
// });
});
How to align each location with local consumer signals
Google Business Profile tactics differ by vertical.
Running every location through the same process may streamline operations, but it sacrifices visibility where it counts.
Using a uniform checklist across all locations will ultimately cost you customers and revenue. Marketers need to revisit and refine their local SEO strategies on an ongoing basis.
The age of the universal checklist is ending; the advantage now lies with brands that can adapt quickly.
- Measure the localization effects: Evaluate each location within its specific market, paying attention to which content and businesses local users actually search for and engage with.
- Prioritize relevant signals: Focus on the GBP elements that matter most for your category. Optimize for what drives relevance, not for habit.
- Implement continuous testing: Treat local SEO as an ongoing experiment. Designate test regions and markets to trial different tactics, monitor performance, and confirm what truly works. The sooner you spot changes in signal fit, the faster you can respond.
- Foster authentic engagement: Reviews are powerful only when they’re part of a dialogue. Fast, genuine responses show both customers and Google that you’re engaged. Real interaction builds measurable credibility.
- Maintain your digital footprint: Keep your Google Business Profile data current. Even small, regular updates can drive noticeable gains. A 1% increase in updates is linked to a 2.23% lift in Google clicks to brand websites. Consistent details across third-party directories also support Google’s validation of your presence.
Why precision will decide who gets seen next
Google is constantly learning from user behavior and adjusting in real time.
Generic SEO frameworks hit a ceiling, and that ceiling eventually shows up as lost revenue.
“Best practices” may keep you from disappearing entirely, but they won’t secure consistent wins in crowded markets.
As artificial intelligence continues to reshape discovery by compressing options into short answers and confident recommendations, the window of who gets exposure will narrow even further.
A highly localized GBP strategy won’t just be a nice-to-have edge; it will be a core differentiator.
Google’s Local Pack already functions like an AI-driven recommendation engine – it rewards relevance, not repetition. For marketers, this is the signal to move beyond generic tactics and lean into precision in local SEO.
Brands that align with localized consumer signals will keep earning visibility long after the current playbook evolves again.
The real risk isn’t choosing the wrong tactic. It’s using the same tactic everywhere.